Coffee Club Comparison: Mistobox Vs. Peace Coffee

By

Bryan Huynh

on December 18, 2024

header image

Key Takeaways

  • Learn the benefits of coffee subscriptions, including the convenience of regular coffee deliveries and access to a variety of coffee beans.
  • Compare Mistobox and Peace Coffee subscriptions, including pros and cons, types of subscriptions, shipping costs, and more.

Following water, coffee is the most popular beverage consumed by people worldwide. Many people rely on coffee daily, and some of them fail to function optimally without it. According to the National Coffee Association, 7 in 10 Americans drink coffee daily. That means that numerous Americans rely on the regular consumption of coffee. Not only do people rely on coffee to help them increase their energy levels, but to some people, coffee simply tastes good. With the wide variety of different coffee beans and flavorings available, many people create gourmet drinks with coffee, both hot and cold.

Coffee is also popular in many social situations, as well, and many people meet at local cafés to share conversation while enjoying a cup of their favorite coffee. Other people spend hours at cafés, as they choose to work on their laptops while enjoying the coffee and the many other goodies that are often on the menu.

For the people who refer to themselves as coffee connoisseurs, ensuring that there is always a new type of coffee to try is exciting for them. They will travel to different places, and even foreign countries, as well as order from various websites just to try out the latest and greatest coffee. That's one of the reasons why coffee clubs, or coffee subscriptions, were created, to allow coffee fanatics to try new coffee regularly, but without the need to leave their homes.

What is a coffee subscription? A coffee subscription is just like any other subscription, and it's when you sign up to receive coffee regularly, without interruption. Some people drink several cups of coffee a day, so they sign up for these coffee subscriptions to have their favorite coffees shipped right to their door, preventing them from ever running out. Even people who only drink one cup of coffee a day, or maybe a cup a few times a week, enjoy the convenience of coffee clubs. Many of these coffee subscribers feel that coffee from coffee clubs is superior to grocery-store coffee, but this is a matter of personal opinion. It also depends on which coffee club you opt for, as there are several available.

If you're considering signing up for a coffee subscription or at least giving one a try, you've probably discovered that there are several clubs to choose from. Out of the many coffee subscriptions available, two popular choices are Mistobox and Peace Coffee. Here are overviews of both coffee clubs, so you can more easily choose the best choice.

How Does Mistobox Work?

Billionaires from the popular TV show Shark Tank invested in Mistobox, and it has proven to be a wise investment due to its immense growth and acclaim. Its popularity has enabled many coffee lovers to enjoy Mistobox coffee since 2011, and their coffee subscription is the perfect way to obtain their coffee. Their subscriptions allow subscribers to access over 600 different types of coffee from 60 different suppliers. That's a pretty impressive number, which is why they have a lot of subscribers.

To sign up for a subscription, you need to answer a few questions, such as how you like your coffee, whether you prefer it black, with cream, with sugar, or some other way. Then you need to choose your grind: do you prefer whole beans or ground? The next step is to choose your favorite coffee roast level: light, medium, dark, or unsure. You will also need to choose a coffee type: single, blend, or espresso. If you're not sure, the coffee experts will make a choice for you or help you decide. If you don't like their choice, you can always switch to a different coffee type in the future.

How often do you want to receive your 12 oz bag of coffee? You can choose anywhere from every week to every four weeks. There are two tiers to choose from. You can opt for Deluxe or Exclusive. The Deluxe option costs as little as $12.86 a bag. The Exclusive is a bit pricier and starts at around $15.26 a bag. Before your subscription can begin, you need to decide how many bags you want to receive with each shipment. As with anything, the more bags you purchase, the cheaper each bag is. You pay $5 for shipping, regardless of how many bags you opt for.

What's Great About Mistobox?

There is a lot to love about Mistobox, but here are some especially impressive aspects:

  • The ability to try more than 600 unique types of high-quality gourmet coffee
  • Your coffee beans are freshly roasted for you just before they're shipped to your home or office
  • You're assigned a personal coffee curator who assists you with choosing the perfect type of coffee
  • Easy to manage your shipments

What's Not So Great About Mistobox?

Again, Mistobox is popular for a reason: because they have a lot to offer. Despite this face, there are a couple of cons, which are:

  • There is a $5 shipping fee for each order
  • There aren't any sampling options

Peace Coffee Subscription

Signing up for a subscription with Peace Coffee is easy, and it works similarly to Mistobox. There are three different ways to subscribe. The first way to subscribe is to simply sign up for the most popular method, which allows you to receive a 5-pound bag of coffee every 4 weeks. Shipping is free, and you have the option to make changes to your subscription at any time following the first shipment.

The second way to sign up for a subscription is to build your own. With the build-your-own option, you can select one coffee or many. It's up to you. You also decide how often you want to receive the coffee, which can be anywhere from every 2 weeks to every two months. If you can't decide how often you want to receive coffee, there is a guide provided that helps you make the determination based on how many cups of coffee you drink each day. Also, you get 15% off every subscription order, as well as free shipping on orders over $40.

The third way to sign up for a subscription with Peace Coffee is to choose the gift option to have coffee shipped to a friend or loved one. You decide whether it will be a one-time gift or ongoing, and you can easily manage the subscription settings anytime, at your discretion. You must cancel shipments for gift subscriptions if you'd only like the recipient to receive a one-time shipment. You can also opt to have multiple gift subscriptions, if desired.

Things to Love About Peace Coffee Subscriptions

Like Mistobox, there's a lot to love about Peace Coffee subscriptions. Here are some things that are especially outstanding when it comes to Peace Coffee Subscriptions:

  • Eye-catching and attractive packaging
  • You get free shipping on all orders over $40
  • Save 15% off coffee when ordered through a subscription
  • You get 30% off on your first order by signing up for their "brewsletter"
  • All their coffee is certified organic, shade-grown, and hand-harvested

Unfortunately, every coffee subscription has cons, but Peace, like Mistobox, is so amazing that there are very few cons. Their two cons are:

  • They don't provide customers with a date on which beans are roasted
  • They offer significantly fewer choices than Mistobox

Mistobox or Peace Coffee Subscription?

It can be difficult to choose between Mistobox and Peace Coffee subscriptions because they both have a lot to offer. If you're concerned about the production of coffee as well as the payment and treatment of the coffee farmers, Peace Coffee should be your choice. The owners of Peace Coffee go above and beyond to ensure that their coffee is sourced from farmers who are paid fairly and treated humanely. Peace Coffee owners also pride themselves on the fact that their coffee is 100% organic. What's so great about organic? Here are just some of the many benefits of drinking organic coffee as opposed to non-organic:

  • Organic coffee has a higher nutrient count
  • Organic coffee has considerably more anti-oxidants than non-organic coffee, and as a result, those who drink organic coffee notice a boost in their immune systems as well as additional protection against many diseases
  • Non-organic coffee contains high amounts of potentially harmful chemicals and pesticides, unlike organic coffee, which is free of dangerous chemicals and pesticides
  • The aroma of organic coffee is richer, the taste is more potent, and it also has a higher amount of caffeine

On the other hand, if you consider yourself to be a coffee connoisseur, and you love sampling as many different coffees from around the world as possible, you will quickly run out of different choices to try with Peace Coffee. Peace Coffee offers only 15 different coffees. While their coffees are delicious and very high quality, you might want to choose Mistobox. Again, Mistobox offers a staggering 600+ coffees, which is an astronomical number of coffees to try.

Not everyone is interested in organic coffee, and many coffee lovers simply want affordable, great-tasting, high-quality coffee, and that's what Mistobox provides. Also, many coffee drinkers find it appealing to know that Mistobox roasts their coffee beans before shipping each order. Freshly-roasted coffee beans have a huge impact on taste, and any coffee drinker knows that the fresher coffee beans are, the more flavorful they are.

Alternately, while Peace Coffee's coffee is 100% organic, they lack transparency when it comes to providing a specific date that coffee beans were roasted. This is an important aspect of the production process that many consumers expect to know. However, if all you want is fresh, great-tasting gourmet and organic coffee, and the roast date isn't important, then Peace Coffee is a good choice.

Which Coffee Subscription is More Affordable?

If you're on a budget, and you want to choose the best coffee subscription based on the choice that is less expensive, then you aren't alone. Many coffee drinkers must consider cost, and some will choose the cheaper subscription in most cases, but not always.

When it comes to Mistobox and Peace Coffee, both choices are relatively affordable. Organic products are typically more expensive, so taking into consideration the fact that Peace Coffee is organic, it's safe to say that their prices are more affordable for what you get.It's also difficult to compare the prices between these two coffee subscriptions because Mistobox's coffee comes in 12 ounce bags while Peace Coffee comes in 20-ounce and 5 pound bags. So, instead of comparing the two based on the price per bag, you can make this determination based on your subscription cost. Several other factors must be taken into consideration when making this decision, including how often you receive your coffee, and a great deal more.

If you are on a budget, you can customize your coffee subscription with either coffee club to meet your needs. Again, the prices are similar, so you might want to base your final decision on something else besides cost.

As you can see, Mistobox and Peace Coffee both offer some pretty outstanding subscriptions. Since they're both so wonderful, it can be difficult to make a final decision on which one to sign up with. You must learn as much about each coffee subscription as possible. You can even find reviews online, and if necessary, you can reach out to both Mistobox and Peace Coffee and ask them any questions that you may have that aren't available online. Remember that if it's your goal to consume as many organic foods and drinks as possible, then Peace Coffee should definitely be your choice, as Mistobox doesn't offer organic coffee.

However, for most coffee drinkers, just because one choice is organic, and the other choice is clearly not organic doesn't mean that the organic choice is superior. If you're serious about choosing the best choice between these two companies, then you might have to try them both out. After doing so, you can analyze things like how long it took the coffee to reach your home or office, the choices available, the taste, quality, what their customer service is like, and more. You should also consider the ease of making your coffee choices, where the coffee is sourced, and any other factors that you find important when choosing coffee. Regardless of whether your final decision leads you to Peace Coffee or Mistobox, chances are you will be quite satisfied with your choice. If, for some reason, you aren't completely satisfied, you could always cancel your subscription and sign up for the other choice, or one of the numerous other coffee clubs that are available. 

About the Author

Product Tester & Writer

Bryan Huynh

Product Tester & Writer

Bryan Huynh is a determined Product Tester & Writer. Being a coffee addict, it is only right that he mainly tests and reviews different coffee from around the world and coffee subscription services.

Bryan Huynh is a determined Product Tester & Writer. Being a coffee addict, it is only right that he mainly tests and reviews different coffee from around the world and coffee subscription services.