Mushroom Coffee Subscription Boxes: Are They Worth It?

Adaptogenic mushrooms can improve your overall health while providing an energy boost, but low quality ones… bleh. Mushroom coffee boxes are a convenient and affordable way to get high quality mushroom coffee delivered straight to your doorstep. But while a good subscription is a delicious delight, canceling a bad one can feel like they’ve invented an Olympic sport of jumping through hoops. 

From Altas+ to MUD\WTR, countless subscriptions exist. So what’s the best one for you? Let’s celebrate the best mushroom coffee subscriptions together and learn which red flags to avoid. 

What Is a Mushroom Coffee Subscription Box?

Subscription services let you customize how you receive your mushroom coffee batches. You can choose the delivery frequency, blend type, price, and more. Subscribers can also get extra perks and exclusive deals, allowing them to save money and time in the long run.  

Here are some common features of a mushroom coffee subscription box:

Custom delivery 

Most mushroom coffee subscription boxes are delivered monthly on a recurring basis, but you can also choose from other schedules. Biweekly is our favorite option since it allows for just the right amount of product without overstuffing your cabinets. 

Blend choices 

You can either choose from an array of different mushroom and coffee combos or stick to one type. Mushroom superblends are a good way to get a variety of adaptogenic mushrooms in your coffee. 

Exclusive features and bonuses

Coffee clubs and subscription services often offer exclusive bonuses to subscribers. For example, you may be able to access exclusive mushroom coffee options that you can’t get anywhere else. 

By subscribing for a long period of time, you could also gain hot streak benefits. Keep an eye out for special subscription benefits when choosing between mushroom coffee boxes.

Discounted bulk pricing 

Annual subscriptions usually come with high-value discounts. This can help you greatly reduce your coffee-related expenditures, which could save you hundreds yearly. 

Wellness guides 

Mushroom coffee is mainly consumed for the health benefits it can give coffee drinkers. Because of this, you will often see a wellness guide that details what adaptogens and mushrooms are included in your box. 

Who offers coffee subscription boxes?

Four Sigmatic: The OG mushroom coffee creator, Four Sigmatic now offers subscription boxes for your convenience and enjoyment. We adore that they abide by an organic, fair-trade mission powered by functional mushrooms. They also perform double extraction to maximize the mushroom’s beneficial potency. You can build your Four Sigmatic subscription bundle today.

RYZE: Rise in the mornings with the RYZE Superfoods mushroom coffee. It comes with a cute mush magnet, spoon, and scoop to make your life easier. The starter kit also includes free gifts, such as mushroom chocolates and a recipe book, to make it even more fun. 

MUD\WTR: The eye-catching name of this brand might draw people in first, but the subscription boxes are what make them stay. MUD\WTR mushroom coffee is USDA-certified organic. We love how they offer Original, Matcha, Turmeric, and Rest blends to give you more customizable options. 

Laird Superfood: Laird offers a wonderful medium roast mushroom coffee starting at $20. If you choose to create a recurring subscription, you get perks like subscriber-only products and exclusive Q&A sessions with experts.

What Comes in a Mushroom Coffee Subscription Box?

Single-origin vs. blended mushroom coffee 

Single-origin coffee is a coffee that comes from a specific farm or region. This usually means you can easily trace back to where the coffee came from. For mushroom coffee, perhaps the subscription box will indicate where the mushroom was harvested. 

Blended mushroom coffee can use beans from several different countries to create a more balanced taste. 

Instant packets vs. ground coffee vs. coffee pods

Instant coffee has been freeze dried for convenience. It is the simplest way to get your daily dose of caffeine. It’s always nice to have a few instant mushroom coffee packets around in case of an uncaffeinated emergency.  

Ground coffee is a more elevated way to enjoy your mushroom coffee. This might be the ideal option if you want to savor the coffee more, since you will still need to brew the coffee. It won’t be instant. 

Coffee pods are small single servings of preground coffee. If you or your business has a coffee machine that is compatible with coffee pods, pods could be a feasible way to source your mushroom coffee. 

Additional wellness products and surprises 

Subscription services try to make every delivery special. Whether that’s a recipe card or a special shroomy blend, it’s always a fun surprise that helps break the monotony of life. 

Mushroom coffee subscription services like to gift subscribers extra items or recipes when sending out deliveries. This lets them show appreciation by making each month’s box more interesting. 

Exclusive flavors and limited-edition releases

Subscribers often get access to special sub-only mushroom coffees. Subscribing can be a great way to sample flavors and blends you might not otherwise try. Who knows — you could even find your favorite mushroom coffee like this. 

Benefits of Mushroom Coffee Subscription Boxes

Convenience

Tired of reordering your favorite roasts manually? Scratch that. Tired of doing things manually, period? The best part of coffee subscription boxes is that they come in automated monthly (or weekly) deliveries. Automation ensures you won’t miss out on your coffee, especially during stressful periods when you just don’t have the time or energy to dedicate to coffee-searching.

Cost Savings & Discounts 

Most brands offer significant discounts for subscribers or coffee club members. You can save costs through:

• Free shipping
• Bundle deals 
• Loyalty rewards
• Discounts on all their products

Even if you’re only saving 15% on coffee, that adds up over the months. Plus, you can save hours on researching and choosing mushroom coffee options. 

Variety & Experimentation

Every month, you can get a new flavor of mushroom coffee without needing to commit to a long period of time. As long as you don’t sign up for 6 or 12 months of subscription at the start, it’s a low commitment process to sub to a mushroom coffee box. 

The rotations help keep your mushroom coffee experience fresh and exciting. 

Exclusive Perks

Beyond cost and time savings, mushroom coffee subscriptions can also give you fun perks, such as:

• Subscriber-only Q&A sessions
• Seasonal flavors 
• Themed recipes like mushroom smoothies or lattes
• Wellness guides for holistic health insights and meditation tips
• Private forums for members to make friends and share their experiences

Downsides of Mushroom Coffee Subscription Boxes

Cost Factor

Subscription boxes for mushroom coffees may have a higher upfront cost. The cost factor depends how much you value the convenience and quality that comes with subscription boxes. Buying single mushroom coffee packs is usually cheaper monetarily.

An issue that comes with subscription boxes in general is that some brands lock you into a long-term commitment. For example, if you sign up for a 12 month subscription, you might be charged high cancellation fees if you decide it’s not for you. Always double check how long you’re agreeing to pay for when subscribing to anything. The pricetag may be low, but make sure you know whether you’re billed weekly, monthly, or annually. 

Subscription Fatigue

We live in a world where everything comes with a subscription. Whether that’s Amazon Prime or Netflix, it’s too easy to rack up bills when ordering subscriptions. If you don’t get around to using your coffee boxes, you can start accumulating too much product and end up losing value. Then, if you forget to adjust or cancel your subscription, you might end up wasting money. Everyone knows the pain of getting charged extra after subscribing to a free or paid trial. 

Lack of Customization

Mushroom coffee hasn’t been around that long. It can be hard to find specific flavors or blends at a suitable price point. You might end up getting ingredients you hate, which is more likely with a mushroom coffee subscription than with a regular coffee subscription. 

Auto-Renewal Hassles

Most of us have tried canceling a subscription, only to find it annoyingly complicated to do so. Some coffee subscription companies make it a slow process to cancel or modify your plan. 

Pro-tip: Check the fine print or customer reviews before signing up for a subscription box. 

Comparing Popular Mushroom Coffee Subscription Boxes  

Atlas+

Atlas is a popular coffee club that offers high-quality single-origin coffees from around the world. Well, now you can get mushroom coffee subscriptions from them too! We’re huge fans of their Superblend+ Free Starter Kit that starts at $19. It nets you 20 daily servings and gives you a good idea about what kind of mushroom coffees to expect.

In addition, your first Atlas+ mushroom Superblend also comes with:

• A free milk frother 
• Measuring spoon
• Wellness booklet
• 30-day guarantee
• Free shipping

You can cancel or adjust your subscription at any time, which makes Atlas+ our top choice for mushroom coffee subscriptions. 

Four Sigmatic

The USDA organic certified Four Sigmatic offers a Focus Ground Coffee that starts at $20. It contains Lion’s Mane and Chaga mushrooms. If you want a mushroom coffee that’s not too earthy or shroomy, Four Sigmatic is a solid choice. 

Everyday Dose

This mushroom coffee is specifically formulated to be digestion-friendly. If you’re worried about coffee acidity, Everyday Dose is an ideal option. This brand blends powerful mushrooms with healthy nootropics. Plus, their mushroom coffees are infused with collagen and L-theanine, which may help ease anxiety and stress. 

We love the Everyday Dose Latte, a blend that is gentle on our stomachs. Their Coffee+ starter kit starts at $27 and they offer 45 day returns (as well as free shipping). 

MUD\WTR

MUD\WTR is certified organic by the USDA, and it’s also a low-caffeine choice (only 35 mg in their original blends). Their box also comes with a cute free frother for your brew. 

The downside to MUD\WTR is its price. Their starter kits cost around $40. Excellent quality? Yes. But also not as affordable, so it’s more of a monetary commitment if you do want to subscribe. 

Who Should Subscribe (And Who Shouldn’t)?

Good for:

• Regular drinkers who consume mushroom coffee daily
• People who enjoy variety and trying new blends
• Those who value convenience over cost 

Not Ideal for:

• Occasional or first time mushroom coffee drinkers
• The budget-conscious who prefer to buy only when necessary
• People who are picky about ingredients or flavors

How to Choose the Right Mushroom Coffee Subscription Box

There are so many mushroom coffee subscription boxes on the market right now. Before starting a long-term subscription, go over this checklist.  

Read reviews and compare brands

Don’t go in blind. Check out our comparison of the best mushroom coffees to learn more about different top brands. Read online reviews and anecdotes to see what customers think of each coffee subscription. 

Check the cancellation policy

Look up the subscription’s cancellation policy before subscribing. It’s best to choose a mushroom coffee subscription service that shows transparency. For example, the Atlas+ Superblend can be modified or cancelled at any time, allowing for more flexibility and control. 

Look for trial options before subscribing to a long-term plan

We all love those free trials. Many brands offer cheaper starter kits with more mass appeal. These selections of mushroom coffees can give you a taste of what could be to come.  

Conclusion: Are Mushroom Coffee Subscription Boxes Worth It?

Subscription boxes for mushroom coffee aren’t for everyone. Their worth depends on your lifestyle and brew preferences. 

Worth?

Drink mushroom coffee frequently? -> Yes. 

Want to try out new flavors? -> Yes. 

Prefer full control over your orders? -> No. 

Want to minimize your costs? -> No.

Have allergens or digestive discomfort? No. 

We recommend trying a one-month trial before you commit long-term to any subscription service.